The Daytime Emmy nominations were announced this week and
didn’t do very well.
As a longtime fan of the show, that doesn’t exactly surprise
me. I have seen what other diehard fans have seen: Some pretty terrible
Still, for GH to fail on the level it did is pretty
Well, first off, GH was left off the best show list. There
were four nominations – and GH wasn’t one of them.
When there were more soaps,
it wasn’t such a big deal to be left off the list occasionally. However, there
are only four network soaps now. Four. There were four nominations. You might
be asking yourself how GH got left off the list – and that’s a pretty good
The fourth soap actually placed on the list was One Life to
– a program that returned for a very limited online run. A show that had
every single person I knew that watched it complaining because it was so bad.
So, there you go. Congratulations GH, you weren’t even
nominated in a category that could have nominated
five shows but didn’t.
The other huge snub was the best writing category. There
were only three nominations – when five were allowed – and GH didn’t make that
I can’t wait to see how Ron Carlivati justifies this.
RC has been basking in some (undeserved) accolades of late.
The ratings for GH were going up – and he was taking credit for them – but the
quality was going down (and he certainly wasn’t taking credit for that). Now ratings are starting to go down again -- and I don't see RC tooting his own horn for that little statistic.
The truth is, GH’s ratings spiked around the 50th
anniversary because beloved vets returned. Fans wanted to see Lucy, Kevin,
Robin, Robert, Frisco, Brenda, etc.
The problem is, the ratings weren’t real. RC managed to draw
back some fans that Bob Guza lost – but he should have whipped out some actual
writing to hold on to those fans. Instead, returning fans found that their vets
were only being trotted out once a month as a gimmick and RC was much more
interested in propping his creations than anything else.
There you have it. For all his bluster and bragging, RC really didn’t
care about what fans wanted. Big shocker there.
He claimed he did. He claimed that he was bringing AJ back
to reinvigorate the Quartermaines. He claimed
Robin’s return was about her love
story with Patrick. He claimed that he was going to go back to GH’s roots and
draw from the show’s history to make it better.
Well, guess what? None of those things happened. AJ is dead.
Robin and Patrick broke up over the phone (after RC wrote the lamest and utterly
unbelievable exit for her possible) and GH’s “history” is wrapped up in
characters we’ve never heard of -- like
Our vets and beloved characters are doing things that they would never do if RC was writing them true to character. And, RC's new creations and pets, are eating up the vast majority of airtime on the soap.
It's a total disaster.
Fans have definitely not gotten what they were promised.
Instead, we’ve gotten one plot device after another. One plot contrivance after
another. One out of character action for a beloved character after another.
That doesn’t sound like respecting fans.
All RC seems to respect is his own agenda. And, as much as I
love GH, I can’t help but be glad that the nominating board sent him a clear
message: You’re so bad you can’t even get a pity spot on the Emmy list.
Yeah, the nominating board would rather have three writing
nominations than offer GH a token bone.
There’s a lesson in there RC. I just don’t think you’re
savvy enough to learn it.
What do you think? Should RC take a hint from being snubbed
from the best writing and best show categories?